CCTV Local surveys show broadcast on the South China tiger photo

 CCTV Local surveys show broadcast on the South China tiger photo, said on Oct. 3 in what happened, some witnesses and Zhouzhenglong the same village had a different view. and in which reporters, Zhouzhenglong on the camera's description There are also many contradictions.
October 3 pm, Shaanxi Zhenping County Town Village Zhouzhenglong text color, text color in Bay Village, Island of God's precious wild South China tigers captured photos. agency issued Zhou Zheng Long photo
Copyright: All marked with grams of Forestry Department of Shaanxi Province, Liu wide publicity director of the Center
new outdoor photographer photographer
Xi Zhinong manufacturer
Luo visit New Year Big Dipper Gallery
Hu Hua Huang Design Director
Suzhou South China Tiger Breeding Base Christine Love
SUN Cheng Qian, deputy director of Shaanxi Provincial Forestry Department of Shaanxi Province
Zhenping County Magistrate Wu Ping Tan Dapeng
Zhenping County Forestry Bureau, Shaanxi Province, Li Qian
Zhenping County, Shaanxi Province, Shaanxi Forestry Bureau
WANG Tingzheng Normal University professor

Xie Yan, Institute of Zoology, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Peking University Law School professor Xi-zinc

Hao Jinsong Cao Yu Qing Rao villagers
State Forestry Administration spokesman
China News December 8 reported 2 months ago, this photo released by the Shaanxi Provincial Forestry Department, declared to the Shaanxi farmer Zhou Zhenglong shooting wild South China tigers have been missing for years, but followed the photo was suspected to be forged, and led to great controversy, even today, there is no calm. photographs genuine dispute, has not only professional or technical problems, but all the scientific spirit of the test events, news surveys tracking the matter.
This is a compelling appraisal, here called by the Chinese Photographers Association of domestic photography, animal photography post production and field experts, the theme to the country caused enormous controversy in the South China tiger in Shaanxi Province to identify the authenticity of photographs .
reason why these photos has attracted the most authoritative of the Photographic Society to organize the appraisal, because in the past month or more, the debate about the authenticity of the South China tiger photo spread, escalating, and this incident caused is usually staged as theater.
10 12, published by the Shaanxi Provincial Forestry Department Zhenping South China tiger taken by farmer Zhou Zhenglong photos, and announced that the wild South China tigers reproduce the Daba Mountain area, but only a few hours later , photo to trigger a huge controversy. Some people think that the true picture, it was judged a fake photo. Some of the photos doubtful. dissenting voices, from experts to the users, mainly from the photo tiger and the proportion of plants, wildlife and other aspects of common sense questioned the authenticity of photos. But in the midst of voices of doubt, the photo photographer photos Zhouzhenglong always insisted is true.
Reporter: South China tiger photo, tiger and the picture is not true?
Zhou Zheng Long: I think that is one hundred percent true, with no false.
insist that there is a real photo photo release party Forestry Department of Shaanxi Province.
off g: I saw him after the photo shoot, I from the heart of his admiration, he is my hero.
photo was taken and the Shaanxi Provincial Forestry Department to say no to dispel people's questions. more and more users to collect photo evidence of false around the authenticity of photos, quickly formed a network to send and quite Tiger Tiger faction.
face of challenge, was to head security Zhouzhenglong photo real, but his camera experience can not be questioned by those who always convincing. October 3, he faced the tiger were taken 71 photos, recording time is 25 minutes, according to the description of Zhouzhenglong his lack of meters away from the tiger, and even recently at only 20 meters, twice in the shooting lights also flash, but the tiger always directly at the camera, neither attack nor flee. In Zhenping local, many residents photographed the tiger for his skepticism.
villagers: Zhouzhenglong so obedient to shoot the tiger, climbed there, motionless.
Reporter: Do you feel very strange is not it? do you feel weird?
Villagers: Tigers this thing is very sensitive thing, or else a cold tiger, it can not move .
Q: how do I feel your village head to this as a joke, come on?
Villagers: actually not a joke, it is actually not a joke, and it eventually became a joke.
but Zhou Zheng Dragon of these disputes have their own interpretation.
Zhouzhenglong: the last press conferences of experts and professors, and I said so, he said you are old Zhou was lucky, I finally verified by many, this is the day to eat the tiger full, it either to eat, what is still today the old Xi'an ah week.
off g: Zhouzhenglong is a great hunter, the hunter in the face of wild animals, some of his initiatives, he matter sorted animals to reach ordinary people of this communication is not what we could have imagined.
Reporter: You said Zhouzhenglong has the power to let the tiger calm.
off g: not to say that such power to make the tiger Zhouzhenglong sedation, but Zhouzhenglong There is a force so close to his face when the Tigers can keep his own composure.
Zhouzhenglong Shaanxi Provincial Forestry Department and can be challenged those who claim not recognized by some animal researchers expressed an objection to this argument. is known as the father of the tiger South China tiger breeding base in Suzhou Huang Christine intelligence experts have taken this evaluation tiger Zhouzhenglong.
Huang Kung situation: it is called its state to death, dying before the state it Fixed.
However, many questions still can not shake that picture real side view. until November 16, one user on the network released a tiger pictures, tiger pictures taken with the tiger highly Zhouzhenglong similar to that found in a South China tiger photos of events is an important turning point.
on December 2 of the Photographic Society organized the appraisal meeting, the participating experts devoted to tiger pictures and shoot the tiger did Zhouzhenglong identity authentication.
Liu Kuan new: we use the six photos, 06,24,27,29,36,40, six photos, this is a animation.
Liu Kuan new: two tigers coincidence, the South China tiger, tiger pictures, the pictures Tigers pull it out to be a single image of two tigers coincidence.
photographer Liu Kuan new After analysis, pictures not only the tiger and the tiger body Zhouzhenglong consistent shooting, and even the eyes, beard and other details at the same height also.
Liu Kuan new: this, here, there is this place, look at next, this picture is the beard, 40 tiger photos and pictures as compared other than Tiger, at least four whiskers overlap.
news of tiger pictures after the release of pictures Zhouzhenglong that is a copy of his photographs. and even once said to an investigation by the proceedings of the New Year.
investigation by users and the media, was questioned paintings Zhouzhenglong manufacturers, as early as in 2002 This has been printed and distributed the called
and disclose such information on the Internet after the New Year has been found throughout the country .11 In late May, a Web site to get the digital photos taken Zhouzhenglong 41, which also makes the experience more than a After months of debate, according to the authenticity of the tiger finally has a new progress. in the prior appraisal, the experts have been through back to back in the form of an analysis of each of the photos, the experts agreed that the photos on the network before it is widely South China tiger photo spread, and photo technology index made enough to identify the authenticity of the photo.
Liu Kuan new: we use ourselves and they are better than the South China tiger, which if there is a change, even the slightest change, we believe that it is a living body, it will change panting Well, so now 06 photographs and 40 photographs, is completely consistent with the wind blowing that will change. Yes, the wind blowing point would have to change. well, look at this, this is 06 and 40 is the first photo and the last one, the basic intervals of 20 minutes, 25 minutes, 25 minutes this time is regarded as exactly the same.
on the use of flash photography through photo analysis, experts believe that photo is very dubious.
Liu Kuan new: we have had your cat, dog, all to have it, according to an animal, if the flash straight on when the animal's eyes are shining, it is like this picture of you I look at it magnified, it is like this in this light. The real eye Where is it?, here it is, see no, only the eyes and the eyes only, which is two eyes, and now the light is the site from the non-eye, nose and forehead piece appeared in this place so much reflection, this place is Tiger Mao Mao's impossible for such a bright reflection, this reflection is only one explanation that has been taken with the bright reflective material, so I judge it is something of a printing, graphic, and inkjet. and finish is very high, for, glossy.
experts from the leaves overhead photo of the tiger Analysis of the formation of the projection made.
Liu Kuan new: I found eight more typical picture of the eight photos you see, we only look at the leaves overhead, you see exactly the same without the leaves, and saw not the same as and more clearly from the two pictures can be seen, the leaves overhead projector on a cloudy day is this the case, the projection relations are very specific, so there specific things that I am at home, in the shadow of the control I have carefully , this distance is no more than five centimeters, in other words, the head of the leaves from the Tiger Tiger is very close, and it nearly to what extent? the leaves are attached according to the above.
Liu Kuan new view: the South Tiger Tiger with the same pictures, the photos in each photo identification of the tiger are the same, live animals can not be firmly in 25 minutes time, a plain old leaves while maintaining a fixed posture. Therefore, we can determine, no South China tigers live animals The shape is, is a static image, is placed in the tiger bush plane model, the body covered with leaves and other objects taken from the edge.
photographer Gao Lei said: two-dimensional image of the tiger image, with independent three-dimensional images, that Tiger is flat. After doing computer analysis of simulations, that the photographer and the Tiger distance between the 11 meters distance in such a wild South China tiger can be a long shot hope that the photos photographer Zhouzhenglong to answer.
team that WESTERN Beijing Film Academy: The test equipment, photo above, the white tiger fur chest clearly appeared bluish. In addition, the tiger to the edge of the picture darker But the tiger is particularly abnormal chest hair and bright, light and shadow effects are not consistent with common sense.
Xi Zhinong: If this picture is real, it is a shame wildlife photographer.
Hu Hua: photo I think there must be lots and lots of doubts.
Liu Kuan new: My attitude is very clear that the tiger South China tiger is downright false, this need not be very complicated to identify, it can be said very clearly, I am the identification results I am responsible.
12 月 3, China Photographers Association's expert conclusion on the announcement, while with the release also includes evidence from China Identification Center, the famous Chinese detective expert Henry Lee, including the views of the other five parties The experts unanimously found that the photos are fake or there is all kinds of doubts. Just after the release of these expert conclusions, the Shaanxi Provincial Forestry Department issued a statement, adhere to the position on November 23, that believe the true picture. and for the majority of users of wildlife protection support.
made by numerous agencies face the South China tiger photo identification of very dubious conclusion, the Shaanxi Provincial Forestry Department insisted that the photo why do the views of the real?
10 later this month, investigative journalist has to South China tiger photos to Shaanxi conducted a survey. At the time, as public information director of Forestry Department of the relationship g accepted our interview. So far, the views of the relevant grams did not change for the photos.
Reporter: I think you must shut Officer also very tired, to accept such a multi-media interviews, it stands to reason that development today, the forestry sector to publish a conclusion that should be very authoritative, and why this conclusion itself has been so much controversy? you have not thought about this problem?
Off g: I can not answer this question, but this really thought-provoking questions, we have organized this work, we release, we are convinced that what we publish is true.
Reporter: what about director, you Can you provide me with what you identify the record at that time?
off g: I do, I can only tell you what the identification process, as the Forestry Department of the face of these things are what a program, I have no right answer because I never organize this appraisal, we have a special department of wildlife management.
Reporter: Well, hold this news conference before the Forestry Department have been sent to the scene to verify this picture?
Off grams: This I do not know.
CCTV happened 3 months, a number of witnesses and Zhouzhenglong the same village had a different view. and in which reporters, Zhouzhenglong description on the camera, there are many contradictions.
on what had Photo identification is how to make, release to the public before such a major discovery compliance with the forestry sector should work procedures, we opened the meeting in Beijing Provincial Forestry Department deputy director SUN Cheng Qian's phone.
Reporter : Director is the case, now I got the news conference pass is issued, the above photo of the Shaanxi Provincial Forestry Department organized the images of wildlife experts and the experts were identified, respectively, in identifying who it is ?
SUN Cheng Qian: participation in the case is based mainly on our Forestry Department.
Sun director of introduction, photo identification at the time, are within the Forestry Department staff, and not the organization of specialized appraisal.
SUN Cheng Qian : But as Zhenping County People's Government and the County Forestry Bureau official to report to me, moving to our Stations and Forestry Department reported several other units, we have repeatedly asked them to conduct on-site verification.
Reporter: Later, inside the county has not submitted to you check the material?
SUN Cheng Qian: oral reports, Zhenping County People's Government and to report to me Zhenping County Forestry Bureau and is committed to the site to verify the location is real.
Interviewer: Did Forestry Why not ask the Office to produce the verification of the information they do?
SUN Cheng Qian: We think that as a local people's government, he promised us this thing is real, I think that is enough, I believe they.
then , Zhenping county government whether Zhouzhenglong been the scene photographs to verify it?
Reporter: this thing before reporting to the ministries and agencies, the county's forestry sector has not been submitted to the site to verify your report?
Ping Wu: Listen Forestry Administration Tanju Chang reported.
Reporter: Tanju Chang has not given you to submit relevant information to verify this survey?
Ping Wu: I do not see him Forestry Department's Tanju Chang are seen.
Reporter: There you?
Wu Ping: Yes.
in some media reports we have seen of them, moving tube station staff told other media, Qian Li, interview, has said : October 6, and the verification that he had taken pictures up the mountain. We found the Li Qian, I hope he can provide on-site inspection on October 6 the information, but he said it could not provide.
Reporter: But you told the media after When interviewed, said Oct. 6 the camera you bring up the mountain, but it also had its own stand in that position until the tiger was so Zhouzhenglong help you take how is this going?
Li Qian: This I do not too well.
Li Qian: Media do not know how to say, I do not know.
Reporter: This is when you open an interview published the information out?
Li Qian: I do not know .
reporter interviewed Li Qian provide us with an interview recorded at the time.
Li Qian: I went to check the time, so he crouched tiger that place, so that when his Tigers as a reference.
Reporter: Why should this happen?
Li Qian: crouching tiger because of his place, I was in his camera that place, if I can not stand in his place according to him, it means that the camera he is a fake.
Reporter: According to you what the camera does?
Li Qian: I am using an ordinary camera.
Reporter: Digital or a fool?
Li Qian: digital camera.
Reporter: According to digital camera, and he compared the situation that is not consistent?
Li Qian: basically consistent.
Reporter: consistent?
Li Qian: I can not remember now, I just said October 6 I went to see the site.
Reporter: video photographs have you?
Li Qian: no.
Reporter: transcripts that are up?
Li Qian: For Zhouzhenglong with no record to be go, but there is no evidence, that I admit.
working procedures in accordance with the forestry sector, on-site inspection as soon as possible within the time required, more than two staff members left behind traces of animals on the spot to make professional measurement, recording and classification. on the surrounding vegetation and geographical environment, an accurate description, but also need to investigate the parties and visits to surrounding people, and make records and preliminary judging in order to ensure timely and reliable verification of the information and complete, but In the investigations we have found that, for the South China tiger taken by Zhou Zhenglong photos of this great discovery there is no verification of information can be proved. It also makes hugely controversial in the photo, the loss of an important and effective means of settlement, however, verification of such a behavior can not prove how it was identified and reported?
Reporter: Li Qian you were there to show that he is against this background that the real evidence?
Tan Dapeng: that is, verbal is one such.
reporter: a person's claim that he alone can do?
Tan Dapeng: Do not believe him please?
Reporter: In addition to his claim, he has no other basis to prove that he been?
Tanda Peng: I'm on my cadre, I was on him, I told them I was very worry, that is, what is the quality of cadres, which are what people, I was very clear. < br> So, the verification of fact submitted to the provincial Forestry Department's Zhenping County informed of this situation is it?
Reporter: Do you believe Tanju Chang at work, so do not ask him to be on-site verification, you must have that , but the results we found that there is no.
Ping Wu: I do not know the situation.
Reporter: just this detail can be seen that such subjective believe that sometimes is very fragile, very difficult to account for the foot is maintained.
Wu Ping: What you say may be a little neglected this.
In the interview, we found that the Provincial Forestry Department is the first time informed the county did not follow procedures to verify this information.
SUN Cheng Qian: Are you going to say that and I am the first to know.
CCTV Tiger photo survey shows that on Oct. 3 in what happened, some witnesses and Zhouzhenglong the same village had a different view. and in which reporters, Zhouzhenglong description on the camera, there are many contradictions place.
early wild South China tigers have been declared extinct 20 years ago, and October 12, the Shaanxi Provincial Forestry Department released photos Zhouzhenglong wild South China tiger taken is undoubtedly a major discovery that shocked the world,
actually , a shooting behavior is not isolated before and after it happens there must be a lot of proof, we interview them, to beat the tiger story Zhouzhenglong do a survey.
statement by Zhouzhenglong, October 3, midnight point to the mountain to find the tiger, the tiger found in drinking water at ten watermark, half past four p.m. or so, hit the tiger, began shooting, he was the last time for a photo shoot 17:03, shot to Shenzhou from Bay walked home another 4,5 hours away, this information Zhouzhenglong has repeatedly been described to the media.
Q: You finished around that time that some of the photos?
Zhouzhenglong: Anyway, I go from the mountain a little more time is 5:00.
Reporter: go back?
Zhouzhenglong: ah, went home at 9 o'clock.
we understand that the afternoon of October 3 some people have seen Zhouzhenglong, we found him.
the sea: 5 pm to 6:30 between the (hit Zhouzhenglong), he said, took on the South China tiger, and I asked him what the machine according to the? he that there are digital film, digital cameras, I say you give me a look, he used digital photos, when I brought looked, he quite mysterious, but I took over he showed me. < br> Yu recalled, October 3 to pick up his relatives to live in literary talent in the village of Zhouzhenglong met Zhouzhenglong way, but the sea was Zhouzhenglong also told that he had photographed the South China tiger photos.
Reporter: October 3rd day, your photo shoot back, you have not encountered in the village who?
Zhouzhenglong: no.
Reporter: Yu said he was driving ran into you on the roadside , got your message after you read the South China tiger photos back to him.
Zhouzhenglong: he was blind say, he did not have the basis of how I might come down the mountain to meet him out? < br> Reporter: Did you meet him, right?
Zhouzhenglong: Where I touched him?
what to say in which sea and Zhouzhenglong true? We know there are other people were on board, We also find that they do check.
Reporter: car and then one day you come back from the outside, you have come across one, holding a camera to the person you see tigers?
met before, and I My mother sat him (at sea) of the car came back to meet him (Zhouzhenglong), and then my brother let him (Zhouzhenglong) stopped by to take him (Zhouzhenglong) back in the car and then he told us, he photographed the South China tiger photos.
Reporter: He is in the car to show you this picture up?
Villagers: The.
Reporter: What to see?
villagers : digital camera it seems.
Reporter: What do you see?
villagers: to see there are two pictures, which have a tiger, and then next are the leaves.
Reporter: Do you When did you remember that day?
Villagers: days just black.
Reporter: What is the date remember?
Villagers: 3 bar.
Reporter: how can you have the impression that 3 what?
village: Because October 1, I was in the homework, go back 2, 3, go back, the second trip when I met him (Zhouzhenglong).
in the October 3 No. happened, these witnesses and produced a very different view Zhouzhenglong. Zhouzhenglong statement in accordance with his 17:03 last photo shoot more than 4 hours away, many did not get home 21:00, However, if according to the villagers that he has no dark days has been to the mountain. and in our interview them, a description of Zhouzhenglong on the camera, there are many contradictions.
Zhouzhenglong: at first sight I like how so much.
Reporter: You were probably far away from it?
Zhouzhenglong: from here on to the top of the tree.
Reporter: cliff on the tree do?
Zhou Zheng Long: It may be farther than that yet.
Reporter: Let's here from.
Zhouzhenglong: ah.
Reporter: What if such estimates, which is a less than 50 meters, right?
Zhouzhenglong : That is more than, I forward the first climb, it just get put up to the ears.
Reporter: every 50 meters so far beyond the tens of meters you can see? tiger ears pricked to do?
Zhouzhenglong: Oh, say it is not clear, anyway, is very near. I do not know that flash is how to open, and I do not make, anyway, so one click, click, click, when I put the machine have got rid of.
Reporter: You have no shot?
Zhouzhenglong: it hears the sound of : But according to your time recording of digital cameras, flash lights when you take more than 30 photos of your first four of them.
Zhouzhenglong: the first four?
Reporter:.
Zhou Zheng Long: There are more than 20 sheets is not?
Reporter: Yes, this is the camera records.
Zhouzhenglong: Now a little bit not remember exactly, in the end is here, flash, or flash here, the time a bit too long.
Zhenping us to interview, photograph Zhouzhenglong from half a month's time has passed, we would like to know, the local government sector in the dissemination of information and the emergence of doubts before, there have been no Zhouzhenglong the filming process more detailed investigation it?
Reporter: the authenticity of the outside world Zhouzhenglong photos are controversial and questionable cases, you've done the research and research in this?
Ping Wu: I think there is no need.
Reporter: Why?
Ping Wu: Because I believe that this picture is real, that is, the people of Zhouzhenglong I think this is an ordinary peasant, and why he wanted to be so complicated to , it seems, and forgery, counterfeiting and linked.
Reporter: But if the research is based not you believe a person's personality, do you think of this scientific attitude?
Ping Wu: we now have a photo to circumstances, we think that is true.
(This article Source: CCTV a
【have 1773 users expressed his views, click View.】
Previous 1 2 3 4 Next